Not great cookie shape, but delicious! The All-Clad D3 Baking Sheet is the cookie holder here.

I wanted to test what many call the “best stainless steel baking sheet” – known as the All-Clad D3 Stainless Steel Roasting Sheet. It could also be called or baking sheet, or cookie sheet. My first test of the All-Clad D3 was with a batch of chocolate chip cookies. Before we get to that, check out my video of the 14″ x17″ Roasting Sheet unboxing and initial impressions:

Initial Video Review – All-Clad D3 Baking Sheet

The piece really does have a nice weight to it.

Cookie Test – Is this the best Stainless Steel Cooking Sheet?

The All-Clad Cookie Sheet held it’s heat very well once the cookies were pulled out of the oven.

My chocolate chip cookies turned out delicious, and this was a recipe I had never done before. They were evenly cooked. I took them out a little early, and then let them continue cooking on the cookie sheet for another 10-minutes and they browned up perfectly. The All-Clad cookie sheet really held the heat well.

Pick up the All-Clad D3 Baking Sheet on Amazon::

Check Current Price on Amazon


Cleaning the All-Clad D3 Stainless Steel Baking Sheet

Cleaning the baking sheet was very easy with our good friend, Barkeeper’s Friend. This stuff is magical for stainless steel. It took about 20 seconds to lightly scrub the cookie sheet and it was sparkling.

Get Bar Keepers Friend on Amazon:


Check Current Price on Amazon


Close Menu